Skip to main

Best Pizza in Stirling

Family operated pizzeria, inspired by Brooklyn

Try our most popular items

Treat yourself to our must-try list that has everyone talking

View Full Menu

Short Rib Lasagna

Add Item

Sorrento Knots

6 pieces. Ham, salami, mozzarella, cheese, in garlic, oil with spices served with a side of sauce.

Add Item

Plain Pizza

Add Item

Chicken Wings

6 pieces. Plain or buffalo.

Add Item

Chicken Parmigiana

Breaded and topped with tomato sauce melted mozzarella cheese served with a side of linguine

Add Item

The Brooklyn Grandma

Plum tomato sauce on top of a layer mozzarella cheese, topped with fresh mozzarella cheese, olive oil & basil

Add Item

The Brooklyn Grandma

Plum tomato sauce on top of a layer mozzarella cheese, topped with fresh mozzarella cheese, olive oil & basil

Add Item

Triple Threat Pizza

Calzone and garlic knots

Add Item

Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza

Add Item

Garlic Knots

Per person. 6 garlic knots. Vegetarian

Add Item
Order From Our Website

Order From Our Website

Order directly from our website to save money in fees, get faster service, earn free food via our rewards program, and support local business.
Order Now

What our guests are saying

Check out our most recent reviews!

Will be coming back again and again! Ordered a plain pie, mussels in red sauce, a house salad, and zucchini sticks. Everything was delicious! The sauce on the mussels was amazing. The pizza is the best I've had in this area by far. Highly recommend!

Elaina R.

Elaina R.

Good pizza. Excellent broccoli rabe with garlic. Big sausage roll. My mother-in-law went crazy for the Calabrese pizza at our social distancing get-together. Good all around.

John W.

John W.

We ordered from here for the first time tonight. Truly awesome, especially for takeout during COVID. From the rice balls for my son who is a vegetarian, to the chicken fingers for my other son, to the mozzarella and peppers for my husband, and finally, chicken and spinach for me, it was all great! Will def be our go-to for ordering going forward.

Monique G.

Monique G.

Featuring

Gluten-Free Options

Healthy Options

Easy Parking

Only Fresh Ingredients

Only Fresh Ingredients
We invest in quality ingredients to ensure our customers get the great taste we’re famous for. Because we believe that you deserve the best.

Made With Love

Made With Love
Our secret ingredient is passion. Everyone on our team is passionate about making your time with us as great as it can be – from start to finish.
Brooklyn Pizza Rewards

Brooklyn Pizza Rewards

Join our rewards program to earn points, get free items, and stay up to date with us.

Discover the difference.

Discover the difference.
With locations in both Short Hills, NJ, and Stirling, NJ, Brooklyn Pizza is proud to bring fresh, authentic Brooklyn style pizza over the river for New Jersey to enjoy. Come on in and taste the difference. Brooklyn Pizza first opened it’s doors in October 2018 in Short Hills, NJ. Our desire is to bring you the fresh and authentic flavors that many have come to associate with the famous pizza that hails from Brooklyn. We source the freshest ingredients and create pizzas and Italian specialties that even your great grandmother would be proud of. We don’t want to be like every other pizzeria around……we want you to taste the difference in our ingredients and the way we cook our sauces, chop our herbs and source our food. We are proud to announce that we have just opened our second location in Stirling, NJ located at 258 Main Ave, Stirling, NJ 07980. Brooklyn Pizza is a family-owned and operated Italian restaurant offering classic Italian cuisine and traditional Italian dishes. We deliver, cater, offer dine-in or take-out service. Come enjoy our newly renovated space.

Frequently asked questions

We serve Breakfast, Lunch, and Dinner

Yes, we offer Takeout and Delivery

Our locations